Skip to main content Skip to search Skip to main navigation
A small mixed-breed dog sitting in front of four bowls containing dry food, wet food, BARF and a fresh meal.

FIND THE RIGHT FOOD FOR YOUR DOG

The LuckyChef Dog Food Check

Dog Food Check: Find High-Quality Dog Food for Your Dog

Dry or wet. Raw or cooked. Sensitive or vegan ...

You have many different options when it comes to feeding your dog. The best feeding method should fit you and your dog individually and provide them with all the essential nutrients they need.

But how can you recognize high-quality dog food?

In the Dog Food Check, we take a close look at different feeding methods and give you an overview:

  • We explain the different feeding methods.
  • We explain the advantages and disadvantages of each feeding method.
  • We tell you what makes high-quality dog food.
  • We give you tips on what to look out for when making your choice.

Our Dog Food Check is continuously updated with new articles.

Simply click on the tiles below to access the detailed pages.

A small white dog sitting in front of a bowl of dry food.

Dry Food 

Light, compact, seemingly shelf-stable forever – and pretty convenient for dog owners. But there’s a trade-off: Dry food is the most heavily processed of all feeding methods.

A black and white coloured damlmatian dog is eating fresh food out of a bowl.

Chilled Fresh Food

Close to home-cooked food. Gently cooked to preserve natural nutrients & aromas. Preserved through refrigeration or freezing.

Corgi puppy with large ears in an office. / A fluffy dog lying in the sun on a bed.

Puppy Food

During the first few months of life, the foundations for the future are laid. Puppies therefore have very different nutritional requirements from adult dogs.

An Australian Shepherd sitting in a light-filled living room next to a bowl of dog food and surrounded by many green houseplants.

Vegan Dog Food

Can a dog be fed a healthy diet without animal-derived ingredients? In short: Yes. High-quality vegan dog food can provide a healthy dog with all the essential nutrients they need.

A Corgi dog happily rolling around on a green meadow.

Sensitive Dog Food

Can support the diet of particularly sensitive dogs and help relieve the strain on the digestive tract. However, “Sensitive” is not a protected term.

A dog sitting in front of a display shelf filled with many different types of canned dog food.

Canned Dog Food

The most well-known form of wet food, available in every price range. However, its long shelf life can come at the expense of natural nutrients. 

Categories of Dog Food

Dog food can be categorized in different ways:

1) How was it prepared? Wet food or canned food, fresh food, BARF, dry food or homemade dog food differ significantly in how they are made.

2) Was it developed for a specific life stage or special needs, such as for puppies or dogs with allergies?

3) Does the dog food contain only specific ingredients, as is the case with vegan dog food, for example?

The overall package of preparation method, individual needs and ingredients determines which dog food is the right choice for your dog.

A BARF meal in a bowl on a kitchen counter.

BARF

As close to the wolf as possible – that’s the principle behind raw feeding. If you feed your dog a BARF diet, you have full control over the ingredients. However, this type of feeding also carries some risks.

A father and daughter standing in a kitchen and cooking together. A Vizsla dog is sitting at their feet and watching them.

Homemade Dog Food

Full of flavour and natural nutrients. Unlike BARF, the ingredients are cooked, making them easier for a dog’s stomach to digest and offering an advantage especially for sensitive dogs.

A man hugging an older dog.

Senior Dog Food

Older dogs have special needs. Not only their bodies, but also their appetite and behaviour can change. Special food can help support senior dogs – but not every dog needs senior food.

Overview Feeding Options

Here you can get an initial overview of the different feeding methods.

Simply expand the sections below and check them out.

Dry food is practical, has a long shelf life and is easy to portion. A very low moisture content is typical of dry dog food.

Depending on the production method, different types include extruded, cold-pressed, baked and semi-moist food.

A good fit if: uncomplicated storage, easy portioning and practicality in everyday life are important to you.

What to look out for: ingredients, meat content, protein sources, product declaration, production method and sufficient water intake.

Read the full Dog Food Check on dry food here.

Wet food contains significantly more moisture than dry food and is popular with many dogs due to its more intense aroma and soft texture.

The best-known form is classic canned food. However, wet food can also be offered in trays, pouches or jars.

A good fit if: your dog prefers soft, moist food or needs to take in additional fluids through their food.

What to look out for: High-quality wet food can be recognized by clear and transparent labelling, natural ingredients and a balanced composition.

Find out what makes high-quality wet food and how canned food is made in our Dog Food Check on wet food.

Fresh food or fresh meals are made from fresh, natural ingredients. Low cooking temperatures help preserve many natural nutrients and aromas.

To ensure a longer shelf life, the meals are generally refrigerated or frozen. Fresh meals combine the benefits of home-cooked food with the convenience of ready-made food and are considered a particularly high-quality option by many dog owners.

A good fit if: you want to feed your dog fresh, minimally processed food but don’t want to cook for them every day.

What to look out for: cooking method, ingredient quality, product declaration, meat content and, above all, whether the fresh food is labelled as a complete food.

Steam cooking, sous-vide or HPP? Our Dog Food Check on fresh food has all the details.

BARF stands for “Biologically Appropriate Raw Feeding”. It involves feeding raw ingredients such as meat, offal, bones, vegetables and oils.

When properly formulated, BARF can give you full control over the composition of your dog’s diet – but it requires a good deal of knowledge to ensure that your dog receives all the nutrients they need in the long term.

A good fit if: you want to learn more about your dog’s nutrition and create their meals individually.

What to look out for: nutrient supply, supplementation, kitchen hygiene, the proportion of meat, offal such as liver and a professionally calculated ration.

Read the full Dog Food Check on BARF here.

When cooking for your dog yourself, you prepare their meals using ingredients such as meat or other protein sources, vegetables, carbohydrates and oils.

Unlike BARF, the ingredients are cooked.

Homemade food can be tailored very individually to your dog’s age, activity level and needs. However, when cooking for your dog yourself, it is also important to have a balanced recipe that fully meets their nutritional requirements.

A good fit if: you want to know exactly what goes into your dog’s bowl and are willing to invest some time in planning and preparation.

What to look out for: a nutritionally adequate recipe, the right supplementation with minerals, vitamins and essential nutrients, as well as essential fatty acids.

What belongs in the bowl and which supplements does your dog need? Find out everything about homemade dog food in our Dog Food Check.

Puppies are in the middle of their growth phase and have different nutritional requirements from adult dogs. Puppy food is available in different forms, for example as dry, wet or fresh food.

What matters is that it is specifically formulated for growth and provides the young dog with all the essential nutrients they need in the right amounts.

What to look out for: a balanced recipe, high-quality protein sources and food that is specifically tailored to the growth phase.

What does a puppy need for healthy development? How can you recognize high-quality puppy food? In our Dog Food Check, we take a close look at puppy food.

As dogs get older, their energy requirements, digestion, appetite and body composition can change.

There is no fixed age at which a dog becomes a senior. Size, breed, activity level and health condition all play an important role.

What to look out for: Your dog’s diet should be adapted to their activity level and individual needs. High-quality senior dog food can help provide older dogs with all the essential nutrients they need in an appropriate and individualized way.

Read the full Dog Food Check on senior dog food here.

Sensitive dog food is intended for dogs with nutritional sensitivities, for example those with sensitive digestion or a suspected intolerance.

However, “Sensitive” is not a protected term. The composition and ingredients can therefore vary considerably from one manufacturer to another.

How can you recognize high-quality sensitive dog food? Look for transparent labelling, well-tolerated protein sources and as few unnecessary additives as possible.

Read the full Dog Food Check on sensitive dog food here.

Vegan dog food contains no animal-derived ingredients: Protein, fatty acids and other nutrients come from plant-based raw materials or are specifically added.

Vegan dog food can also be a good choice for your dog if it fully meets their individual nutritional needs and they enjoy it.

Would you like to learn more about feeding dogs a vegan diet and find out what you need to look out for? Read our full Dog Food Check on vegan dog food here.

Hypoallergenic dog food is primarily used when a food allergy is suspected or has already been diagnosed. A food elimination trial with hypoallergenic dog food can help identify potential allergy triggers. Depending on the diagnosis, this may involve hydrolyzed proteins or selected protein sources.

How does a food elimination trial work and what is truly hypoallergenic? Read our Dog Food Check on hypoallergenic diets.

Gastrointestinal dog food is intended for dogs with sensitive digestion, for example in cases of diarrhea, vomiting, heartburn or recurring digestive issues. Easily digestible ingredients, a moderate fat content and a suitable recipe can help relieve the strain on the stomach and intestines.

Which food is suitable always depends on the cause of the symptoms and your dog’s individual needs. If symptoms persist or keep recurring, the underlying cause should be assessed by a veterinarian. How can you recognize gastrointestinal dog food and what should you look out for when choosing it? Read our full Dog Food Check here.

Vegetarian dog food contains no meat or fish but can include animal-derived ingredients such as eggs or dairy products. A balanced vegetarian recipe can provide a dog with all the essential nutrients they need and can therefore also be suitable for long-term feeding.

What matters is that the food is formulated to meet the dog’s nutritional needs and labelled as a complete food. Vegetarian does not automatically mean better tolerated or hypoallergenic. What matters when choosing vegetarian dog food and what should you look out for? Read our full Dog Food Check on vegetarian dog food here.

Insect-based dog food uses insects as a source of protein instead of conventional types of meat such as beef, chicken or fish. The larvae of the black soldier fly (Hermetia illucens) are particularly common. Insect protein can be an interesting option for dogs that do not tolerate certain conventional protein sources or need a novel source of protein.

However, insect-based food is not automatically hypoallergenic, and not every product is automatically nutritionally complete. What matters is the specific recipe, its nutrient supply and whether it is labelled as a complete food. What makes insect-based food special and what should you look out for when choosing it? Read our full Dog Food Check on insect-based dog food here.

A tricolour dog lying next to a bowl of dry food and dozing.

Gastrointestinal Dog Food

Easily digestible, gentle on the stomach and designed for sensitive digestion. The right recipe can help relieve the digestive tract during acute symptoms – but persistent problems should still be assessed by a veterinarian.

A woman in a blue dress holding a growing plant in both hands.

Vegetarian Dog Food

No meat or fish, but certainly not without nutrients. A balanced vegetarian recipe can meet a dog’s nutritional needs – what matters is the composition and quality of the complete food.

A BARF meal in a bowl on a kitchen counter.

Insect-Based Dog Food

Unusual in the bowl but nutritionally interesting: Insects provide high-quality protein and can offer dogs a novel protein source. Particularly interesting for dogs that do not tolerate conventional types of meat well.

How to Find the Right Dog Food

There is no single feeding method that is automatically best for every dog. What matters is not whether the food is dry, wet, raw or fresh.

You can recognize high-quality dog food by whether it meets your dog’s nutritional needs and suits their individual requirements.

To find high-quality dog food, you should pay attention to the following:

  • Meeting nutritional requirements: If the food is intended to provide your dog’s complete diet on a long-term basis, it should be labelled as a complete food.
  • Life stage: Puppies have different nutritional needs from adult dogs or senior dogs.
  • Health: Medical conditions, allergies or digestive problems can create specific nutritional requirements.
  • Tolerability: It is always important to consider how well your dog tolerates a particular food.
  • Ingredients and declaration: A transparent ingredient list makes it clear what actually ends up in the bowl.
  • Production: Processing affects factors such as shelf life, texture and nutrient retention.
  • Everyday practicality: Even the best nutritional concept needs to fit into your life. Storage, preparation time and handling therefore also play a role.
  • Taste: Above all, your dog gets a say. A nutritionally complete food is of little use if your dog does not enjoy eating it.

Best Dog Food Brand

Many dog owners wonder whether there is one best dog food brand.

The answer is: No.

A well-known brand is not automatically a sign of high-quality dog food. What matters is the composition, the product declaration, the ingredients used and whether the food meets your dog’s individual needs.

Your Guide: LuckyChef Dog Food Check

With the LuckyChef Dog Food Check, you can learn more about the different feeding methods and find out which one is best suited to you and your dog.

Do you have any questions? Is something missing? Then get in touch with our editorial team:

etrieba@luckychef.com