Skip to main content Skip to search Skip to main navigation
A Husky sitting in a kitchen and waiting for its bowl of BARF food.

BARFing Your Dog – Benefits, Disadvantages and What to Look Out For

Which dog food is right for your dog? In the comprehensive LuckyChef Dog Food Check, we compare the most important feeding options and show you what matters when choosing the right one. In this article, you'll learn everything you need to know about BARF.

You can find a complete overview of all feeding options on our Dog Food Check topic page.

What Is BARF for Dogs?

Four letters, countless discussions: BARF is probably one of the most debated feeding options for dogs. The abbreviation stands for Biologically Appropriate Raw Feeding. The idea behind it: The dog should eat like its ancestor, the wolf.

BARFing means feeding dogs primarily with raw ingredients such as meat, offal, bones, vegetables and oils. Individual ingredients are purchased, cut or minced at home and appropriately supplemented, meaning with additional nutrients. 

Alternatively, there are frozen BARF mixes, for example from specialized BARF stores or online shops, which may also need to be supplemented individually depending on the product.

Originally, BARF stood for “Born Again Raw Feeders”, a term coined by Canadian Debbie Tripp. 

Later, the meaning changed to “Bones and Raw Food”. Today, in German-speaking countries, BARF stands for “Biologically Appropriate Raw Feeding”. 

The Australian veterinarian Dr. Ian Billinghurst is considered the founder of the modern BARF movement. In 1993, he published his book “Give Your Dog a Bone” after observing health improvements in his own dogs through raw feeding. 

Since then, BARF has become an established term in dog nutrition, although veterinarians and nutrition experts continue to have different views on the method.

Which BARF Models Are There?

Depending on the model, the composition, ingredients and nutrients of a BARF menu can vary. 

BARF: The Prey Model Principle

For more information, simply expand the section below. 

The prey model principle describes the basic idea behind all BARF variations: The diet is designed to replicate what a wolf would eat after killing prey. 

A typical prey animal consists of approximately 

  • 30 percent muscle tissue, 
  • 20 percent skin and fur, 
  • 19 percent bones, 
  • 16 percent of the gastrointestinal tract, 
  • 3 percent internal organs, 
  • 3 percent blood, and 
  • 9 percent other parts such as teeth, eyes or claws. 

Since components such as fur, gastrointestinal contents and blood are rarely fed in practice, following the prey model principle can often result in nutritional gaps. These need to be specifically balanced to ensure a complete and balanced diet.

BARF: The Prey Model Raw (PMR)

For more information, simply expand the section below.

Prey Model Raw, or PMR for short, is based as closely as possible on feeding the whole prey animal. 

Ideally, whole prey animals or at least their typical components such as meat, bones, organs, skin and fur are fed, without any vegetables, fruit or grains. 

The concept does not include plant-based ingredients, as these play only a minor role in the natural diet of wolves and wild canids.

BARF: Feeding According to the Frankenprey Model

For more information, simply expand the section below.

Frankenprey is a variation of the Prey Model Raw and gets its name from Frankenstein, because a “prey animal” is artificially assembled from different individual parts. 

Instead of feeding a whole animal, different types of meat, bones and organs from various animals are combined to replicate the nutrient composition of a natural prey animal as closely as possible. 

Here, too, the diet usually consists entirely of animal-based ingredients, without vegetables or grains.

BARF According to Billinghurst

For more information, simply expand the section below.

The BARF concept developed by Ian Billinghurst involves a much more varied diet composition. 

Over a two-week period, for example, Billinghurst recommends 

  • 16 meals of raw meaty bones or fish, 
  • four meals of vegetables, eggs, cottage cheese, yogurt or fruit, 
  • four meals of offal and two meals of plain meat, as well as 
  • two fasting days. 
The diet is supplemented with ingredients such as brewer’s yeast, algae, vitamin C, garlic and various oils. 

To this day, this model forms the basis for most BARF diets.

A small dog in a person’s arms looking down at a bowl of homemade dog food.

BARF Ingredients

A typical BARF diet consists of several ingredients that provide different nutrients. 

  • Muscle meat from different animal species such as beef, chicken, turkey, lamb or veal provides primarily high-quality protein. 
  • Offal such as liver, kidney, spleen or lung provides important vitamins and trace elements, such as vitamin A and copper from the liver, iron from the spleen or iodine from the thyroid gland. 
  • Larynx, gullet and trachea add connective-tissue-rich components to the diet. 
  • Bones, such as poultry necks, ribs or marrow bones, provide calcium, phosphorus, magnesium, copper and zinc. 
  • Vegetables, fruit and herbs provide fiber, secondary plant compounds and B vitamins. 
  • Oils such as salmon oil or cod liver oil provide essential fatty acids such as omega-3 as well as vitamin D. 
  • Supplements, meaning ready-made nutrient mixtures, help compensate for typical nutritional gaps in raw feeding. 
  • Many dog owners also use products such as brewer’s yeast, eggshell powder or algae.

Benefits of BARFing

Freshness: The ingredients are fed raw and without industrial processing. 

Transparency: The owner knows exactly which ingredients end up in the bowl and where they come from. 

No additives such as preservatives: Since the ingredients are freshly processed, many industrial additives are eliminated. 

Individual: BARF can be flexibly adapted to individual needs, for example in cases of food intolerances, allergies or when a bland diet is required. 

Engagement: Larger pieces of meat and meaty bones often provide longer chewing times.

Disadvantages of BARFing

Possible nutritional deficiencies: An unbalanced BARF diet can lead to deficiencies or excesses of certain nutrients. A study by Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich examined 95 self-prepared BARF diets and found that 60 percent of the daily portions had at least one significant nutritional imbalance. 

Iodine intake was particularly affected, with around 50 percent of the diets providing too little, while vitamin A intake was too low in around 25 percent and calcium intake was significantly below the required level in around 10 percent of the diets. 

Risk of infection: Raw meat can be contaminated with pathogens such as Salmonella, Campylobacter or Toxoplasma. According to studies, 20 to 80 percent of raw meat products from commercial BARF suppliers are contaminated with Salmonella, often due to improper storage. This also poses a risk to people in the household, particularly children, pregnant women or immunocompromised individuals. 

Injuries caused by bones: Feeding bones can lead to dental damage, constipation caused by so-called bone stool or injuries to the digestive tract. 

Time and effort: BARF requires fresh preparation every day, careful calculation of the diet and time for shopping and storage. When done properly, BARF is more time-consuming than is often assumed.

Practical Experience: Veterinarian Hanna Holster on BARF

“I actually like the basic idea behind BARF and find it quite appealing for dogs: fresh ingredients, plenty of aroma and a diet that is intended to be closer to what a natural prey animal would provide. The problem starts when this idea is reduced to an overly simple calculation. 

A bit of everything from the meat counter, some offal, a little vegetables, oil and bones – and suddenly the dog is supposed to be getting everything it needs. 

Unfortunately, it’s not that simple. A diet can look very natural and still be nutritionally far from balanced. Calcium, trace elements, vitamins and essential fatty acids cannot simply be measured by eye. 

Nutritional deficiencies and imbalances often develop gradually and usually only become noticeable once they have already had an impact. The risk of bacterial contamination is also part of the reality of BARF. Raw meat can contain Salmonella, Campylobacter and other pathogens – and they respect neither kitchen hygiene nor romantic ideas about natural feeding. They can enter the household via hands, knives, bowls, work surfaces and floors, and spread further into the environment through feces. The dog does not even have to appear sick. It can look perfectly content, enjoy its raw meal and then shed pathogens. Medically unremarkable, but still relevant from a hygiene perspective. 

Especially in households with young children, older people or immunocompromised individuals, what seems like a natural feeding concept can quickly turn into a rather unnecessary microbiological group project. 

My conclusion: Natural feeding? Absolutely. But recreating a prey animal is by no means the same as calculating a nutritionally complete diet. BARF can work – with expert knowledge, consistent hygiene and a truly nutritionally balanced formulation. Without these, it remains above all one thing: well-intentioned.”

Tips for BARF Feeding

For your dog to benefit from raw feeding, it's not only about choosing the right ingredients but also about how you implement it in everyday life. 

The transition to BARF should be gradual so that the digestive system can adjust to the new feeding method. Many dog owners wonder after switching too quickly: Why does my dog have diarrhea after starting BARF? This is common when the transition happens too quickly. 

Dogs fed a BARF diet can also experience diarrhea over the longer term. This is usually caused by increased bacterial contamination and reduced digestibility due to the raw ingredients.

The daily BARF amount primarily depends on the dog’s body weight, age and activity level. 

  • For an adult, healthy dog, the general guideline is around 2 to 3 percent of body weight per day. 
  • Puppies require 4 to 10 percent of their body weight during the growth phase. 
These values are only rough guidelines. Since nutritional needs can vary considerably depending on activity level, health status and life stage, the individual diet should ideally be discussed with a veterinarian or specialized pet nutritionist and adjusted regularly.

BARF does not work without supplements. Meat, bones, vegetables and fruit alone cannot meet a dog’s nutritional needs. The best way to determine the right combination is to work with a veterinarian or pet nutritionist. 

There are now also many ready-made BARF supplement mixes available on the market. 

In any case, a high-quality oil such as salmon oil is important as a source of omega-3 fatty acids. You should also ensure an adequate supply of iron, calcium, vitamins A, D and E, iodine, zinc, copper and manganese, as these nutrients are often lacking in unbalanced BARF diets.

FAQ BARF

Here we answer important questions about BARF for dogs.

We introduce all other feeding options in our comprehensive Dog Food Check.

Are you missing something? Feel free to contact our editorial team!

etrieba@luckychef.com

Is BARF Suitable for Beginners?

BARF is possible for beginners, but it requires thorough preparation: Dog owners are responsible for putting together a nutritionally balanced diet and should familiarize themselves with the basics beforehand to avoid deficiencies or over-supplementation.

Is BARF Healthy?

When properly formulated, BARF is neither inherently healthier nor less healthy than other types of dog food. What matters is a nutritionally balanced, carefully planned diet, as unbalanced BARF diets can pose a significant risk of nutritional deficiencies.

Disadvantages: Why Not BARF?

The main arguments against BARF are the risk of nutritional imbalances or deficiencies, including inadequate levels of vitamins and minerals, the risk of transmitting pathogens through raw meat, and the risk of injuries caused by bones.

How Much Does BARF Cost per Month?

Monthly costs depend largely on the size of the dog, the types of meat used and where the ingredients are purchased. Depending on the quality and supplier, costs can vary considerably, so it is worth comparing the costs for your individual dog.

Which BARF Provider Is the Best?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer, as it depends on the source and quality of the raw ingredients, hygiene and composition. It is important to look for nutritionally complete recipes as well as proper storage and handling.